Urban Graveyards: 5 Notorious New York Body-Dump Sites

When news broke that a sex offender had been arrested after his girlfriend’s torso, arms, and legs were found at a trash facility in the Bronx, many horrified online commenters wondered how it was possible for a body to be dumped in such a densely populated area.

Related: Police: Sex Offender Threw Woman’s Dismembered Remains In The Garbage

Police say that a sanitation worker was strong-armed into helping convicted sex offender Somorie Moses get rid of the remains of 32-year-old Leondra Foster, according to the Daily News. If an eagle-eyed bulldozer operator had not spotted her remains, Foster’s body could easily have disappeared forever among mountains of trash.

It may seem hard to believe in a city of more than 8 million people, but urban graveyards are hiding in plain sight.

Here are five more that have made headlines:

1. Ocean Parkway/Gilgo Beach, Long Island

Gilgo Beach [Photo: Catherine Townsend/Investigation Discovery]

Gilgo Beach [Catherine Townsend/Investigation Discovery]

It’s been six years since police discovered more than 10 bodies around Gilgo Beach on Long Island while investigating Shannan Gilbert, a 24-year-old escort who disappeared in May 2010 after meeting a client she had arranged via Craigslist.

The case remains unsolved, but it’s clear that the “Long Island Serial Killer” chose this desolate stretch of highway for a reason: It’s remote, and the thick vegetation means that a body left there could be invisible from the highway even if it was only dumped a few feet away.

Related: Six Years Later: Who Is The Long Island Serial Killer?

In 2011, clinical and forensic psychologist Barbara Kirwin told the Daily News: “That desolate stretch of Gilgo Beach is a haunted graveyard, and what holds it all together is that it is an unpatrolled, completely private and deserted place where you can dump a body.”

While searching for bodies, rescuers in the LISK case battled pine trees infested with poison ivy and had their clothes — and skin — torn by the prickly underbrush.

Learn more about the Long Island Serial Killer in Investigation Discovery’s original series People Magazine Investigates. Watch full episodes with ID GO.

2. The East River 

East River near the United Nations [Photo: Wikimedia Commons]

East River near the United Nations [Wikimedia Commons]

New York City’s East River has long been a dumping ground for dead bodies — and, sadly, a popular suicide site.

According to New York Magazine, bodies dumped in the river during the winter months often stay underwater and don’t resurface until April, when decomposition speeds up. The New York Daily News refers to the phenomenon, when the river’s waters warm, as the “Rites of Spring.”

Related: Update: Body Of 7-Month-Old Baby Found After Suicidal Dad Throws Son In River, Then Jumps Himself

Notorious serial killer Joel Rifkin dumped body parts of at least two of his victims in the East River. Between 1989 to 1993, it is believed that Rifkin murdered and dismembered between nine and 17 bodies.

Memorial at Fountain Avenue near Belt Parkway [Photo: Wikimedia Commons]

Memorial at Fountain Avenue near Belt Parkway [Wikimedia Commons]

3. Fountain Avenue

Fountain Avenue is a street in Brooklyn that runs from Atlantic and Conduit Avenues in the north to the Belt Parkway in the south. It’s a desolate, industrial area where vacant lots and abandoned brick buildings are juxtaposed with landfill and swamplike forest growth.

Fountain Avenue has been infamous as a dumping ground for bodies of the Mob since the 1930s, when a group known as Murder, Inc. used the area as a dumping round.

Related: The 5 Most Unforgettable Mobster Nicknames

Later Roy DeMeo, a Gambino soldier, was said to have disposed of as many as 200 bodies in the area. The most recent body discovered was Imette St. Guillen, a John Jay College graduate student, on February 25, 2006. Her body was wrapped in a blanket with packing tape around the eyes and mouth, and lying on a bank overlooking Jamaica Bay.

4. Pelham Bay Park

Pelham Bay Park is the largest park in New York City and extends from the upper Bronx into Westchester County. From 1986 to 1995, at least 65 bodies were discovered in the park, according to the New York Times. The park’s remote location, accessibility from a nearby highway, and complete darkness also made the area a hotspot for ritualistic animal sacrifices. In the early 1990s, a young police officer saw two men exit the woods late at night, and when he stopped to question them, he noticed their blood-stained hands. Thinking that the men may have been shooting animals in the woods, he questioned them. They insisted that the officer would not find any dead animals in the woods, so he let them go — and later discovered a dead human.

Related: 4 Bodies Found In 4 Different NYC Parks, All Discovered Since Thursday

5. The Meadowlands

Though technically located in New Jersey, the swampy Meadowlands area has long been known as another area where corpses simply disappear. The Mob used the area to dump toxic materials as well as dead bodies in the area, which has remained a vital home to birds and other waterfowl. Rumor has it that Jimmy Hoffa’s body is buried in the area, but no trace of his remains have ever been found.

Related: Jersey Girl Says Guido She Met On OK Cupid Stole Her Jewelry And Her Car

Read more:

The New York Times

NJ.com

Main photo: Memorial at Fountain Avenue near Belt Parkway [Wikimedia Commons]

  • I’ve profited 104 thousand bucks previous year by freelancing on-line a­n­d I did that by wor­king part time f­­o­­r several hrs on daily basis. I followed a money making model I was introduced by this web-site i found on-line and I am so amazed that I was able to earn so much money. It’s beginner-friendly a­­n­­d I am just so blessed that i discovered it. This is what i did… STATICTAB.COM/6mairvf

  • Martha Bartha

    Zoo Jersey used to be a dumping ground.