Murderous Moms: Marci Webber, The “Divine Mercy” Throat Slasher

BLOOMINGDALE, IL — On November 3, 2010, 43-year-old Marci Webber loaded her four-year-old daughter Maggie up on Benadryl and sleeping pills, and placed the child in a bathtub.

From there, Marci sliced Maggie’s throat open with a single blow of such force that the toddler’s head nearly came off. Marci then cut her own wrists and neck in an attempt to commit suicide. She also left a haunting note behind, written in blood on the wall above the tub: “Divine Mercy.”

Related: The Lust Life Of Casey Anthony: 3 Sex Shockers And Secret Allegations

Mallory Webber, Marci’s 18-year-old daughter, happened on the scene several hours later and called for help. Little Maggie didn’t make it. Marci did survive, however.

When asked why she’d committed such carnage, Marci said she did it to prevent Maggie from becoming “an Internet sex slave.” She believed online predators were on the way to take her daughter.

Marci Webber [DuPage County Sheriff's Office]

Marci Webber [DuPage County Sheriff’s Office]

Authorities initially charged Marci with first-degree murder and set her bond at $5 million. But as investigators soon found out, Marci Webber had been contending for years with mental illness and alcoholism. She suffered from paranoid delusions and even hallucinations.

Related: Indiana Mom Brandi Worley Kills Kids Over Custody; Dad Had Sought Divorce Advice on Reddit

Exacerbating Webber’s condition at the time of the killing was a custody battle with an ex over a third daughter in Long Island. She and the two girls were staying with Webber’s mother in Bloomingdale, a suburb of Chicago. In addition, Webber claimed she’d had to flee the East Coast because members of a secret society were following her there.

When the case came to trial in 2012, the court quickly ruled Webber not guilty by reason of insanity. She was immediately transported to Illinois’s Elgin Mental Health Center where she was detained for the next four years.

Related: Mom Allegedly Kills Toddler During Text Fight With Dad, Sends Video of Dead Child With Laughing Emoji

Webber filed a petition in 2014 to be released. She claimed she was no longer insane and, as such, posed no danger to herself or anyone else. In July 2016, Webber got a court hearing to argue for her freedom. Cindy Perlin, a licensed clinical social worker assigned to the case, backed up Webber’s bid.

She claimed that Webber’s violence resulted not from the killer mom’s inherent mental illness, but from a reaction to wrongly prescribed medication. Perlin also claimed Webber had been abused at the Elgin facility, stating online:

“She has been assaulted by other patients 15 times, sometimes at the provocation of staff. Two members of the staff even encouraged her to kill herself and provided her with the means to do so…. Marci refused treatment with psychiatric drugs there, which allowed her to recover from her mental confusion. She is lucid and not psychotic, despite her very difficult circumstances. She is not a danger to herself or others.”

At present, Marci Webber is still being held at the Chicago Read Mental Health Center. She awaits her next court hearing and, most likely, is hoping for some mercy, divine or otherwise.

For more Murderous Moms, watch full episodes of Investigation Discovery’s Evil Stepmothers, Deadly Women, and more on ID GO.

Read more:

NBC Chicago
Huffington Post
Chicago Tribune
Times Union
Mad in America

Main photo: Marci Webber [DuPage County Sheriff’s Office]

  • Janene McClafferty

    Wonder if her social worker is sure of herself enough to let that nut live with her if she gets out??

  • Marcedes Moody

    @Janene- I HIGHLY doubt it lol.

    I can’t even begin to explain how disgusted with all these women horrifically murdering their own babies and then just saying “oh but I’m crazy, so it should be fine” WTF, really, 4 years shes supposed to be in a psych ward and then what? For arguments sake lets say she is actually psychotic, isn’t that actually worse than being sane and deciding to hurt or kill people. They make a choice, it would appear by everyone’s claims of insanity their violence isn’t of their own doing, it’s manic, unpredictable and uncontrollable. I’m sorry that is immeasurably more frightening to me. She should never be released.

  • Jessica Speiden

    I had no idea she was attempting to get released, I will be contacting dupage county official’s in the morning as i am just seeing this.
    In 2011 i was pregnant, and had to deal with some past mistakes, i was sleeping in a cell no more than 3-4 yards from this animal, and let me tell you, she never was crazy, shes freaking manipulative and very aware of what she did!!!
    She never shed a single tear for her dead daughter, but she cried PLENTY for herself being in jail!!!

    • SbrChk88

      wow that’s crazy.

    • Jean Berry Merritt

      That was 6 years ago when she was still on meds.

  • Jean Berry Merritt

    I have known and have been friends with Marci since 3rd grade. Since I pretty much know most everything about her and am familiar with mental illness having a brother that is schizophrenic, I hope you would at least pay attention to the details about the medications in the story. It might help someone else. Oh and BTW she has shed many tears over her daughter and still does. Remember she was still taking anti psychotic drugs in jail.

    • Jean Berry Merritt

      Forgot to mention there are many false statements in this article

  • Ali

    Jail seems like a good option if she doesn’t want to be in the hospital anymore: