The Murder Of 13-Year-Old Dylan Redwine: Did Dad Do It?

Dylan Redwine [La Plata County Sheriff’s Office]

VALLECITO, CO — On November 19, 2012, 13-year-old Dylan Redwine disappeared while staying with his dad, Mark Redwine, in southwest Colorado.

Related: Thanksgiving Cold Case — Who Killed 13-Year-Old Dylan Redwine?

It was a court-ordered Thanksgiving visit, a condition of the notably nasty divorce and custody battle Mark had engaged in with Elaine Hall, his ex-wife and Dylan’s mom.

On the day Dylan vanished, Mark told police that he’d gotten up early to run errands and opted to let his son sleep in. Upon returning, Mark said, Dylan was gone.

For the next seven months, investigators combed through every possibility while Dylan’s loved ones continually held out hope for his return. All that ended on June 27, 2013, in the worst way possible.

Related: Cold Case Update — New Developments In The Death Of Dylan Redwine

A handful of Dylan’s bones turned up in the woods of Middle Mountain, about 12 miles away from his father’s house. Searchers also found a piece of Dylan’s shirt, one sock, and a shoelace.

Authorities continued to hunt for clues over the next two years. In the meantime, Elaine Hall expressed no doubt as to who she believed killed Dylan. Appearing on The Dr. Phil Show in May 2015, Elaine said of her ex-husband: “He murdered his son.”

Related: Family Begs Mentally Ill Mom To Reveal Location Of Her Two Missing Children

In the course of the show, Cory Redwine, Dylan’s brother, backed up his mom. They also both stated that they believed Mark moved Dylan’s remains to the canyon-heavy Middle Mountain to more effectively conceal the boy’s body.

As the episode progressed, Mark called in and set off a firestorm.

Related: 4 Ways To Keep Your Kids Safe In Honor Of National Missing Children’s Day

Elaine asked Mark if he would be open to her going with the police to walk through his house and re-create the circumstances that led up to Dylan’s disappearance. She added: “That would be very helpful in the investigation.”

Taken aback, Mark replied:

“We’ve had every opportunity to get those things done before now and at this point I just don’t see the value in doing it. To be honest with you, I refuse to do that. I don’t owe the nation an explanation as to what I’m doing. Dylan is my son!”

Mark also refused to submit to a polygraph test.

Three months later, on August 19, 2015, the La Plata County Sheriff’s Office officially declared Dylan’s death a homicide. The police also named Mark Redwine as the only “person of interest” in the murder.

Related: According To The FBI, A Child Goes Missing In The U.S. How Often?

From there, Dylan’s parents took their hard feelings for one another to court. Elaine sued Mark for wrongful death. Mark countersued Elaine for “intentionally inflicting emotional distress” by making her accusations. Both cases got tossed out of court.

A 2016 search unearthed more “items of interest,” but has thus far led to no significant announcements, let alone an arrest.

Related: Johnny Gosch, the Original “Milk Carton Boy,” Is 47 and Still Missing

Dylan Redwine would have turned 18 on February 6, 2017. Dozens assembled in Bayfield, Colorado, to remember him with a public celebration of his life. Mark Redwine did not attend. Elaine addressed the crowd with gratitude and also wrote on Facebook:

“Happy 18th birthday, my sweet, sunny son. I wish you were here with us to celebrate your birthday. Many will gather to remember you and your sweet self. I miss you more with each passing day. Thank you to everyone for helping us remember Dylan. Until we meet again please keep watching over us. I love you, Dylan Redwine.”

On June 5, Mark announced he would lead a “recovery search” for Dylan’s remains and other clues to be mounted from August 4 to August 11.

As he remains the sole person of interest in Dylan’s murder, a reporter asked Mark if this new effort is, at least in part, to clear his own name. Mark responded, “It’s not acceptable. We’re here five years later down the road, and [Dylan] is still unaccounted for. That is my motivation, to bring him home.”

Read more:
CBS Denver
Facebook Page
Dr. Phil
Durango Herald
Denver Post

Main photos: Dylan Redwine [La Plata County Sheriff’s Office]

  • 1azreader

    Thank you for doing this story! Justice for Dylan

    • On June 5, Mark announced he would lead a “recovery search” for Dylan’s remains and other clues to be mounted from August 4 to August 11.

  • Terri McGinness

    <3 Dylan <3

    • On June 5, Mark announced he would lead a “recovery search” for Dylan’s remains and other clues to be mounted from August 4 to August 11.

  • Tonnie

    I don’t see the value in Mark leading a “recovery” effort. His remains have been found, he’s dead. How would finding more bones lead to an answer in this? Something like a walk-thru of his home the day of the disappearance might. But with his ex-wife trying to get him to do this, he’s right to assume they’re not looking for what happened, but a way to prove he killed his son, which they obviously believe. I don’t blame him for not allowing it or not taking the polygraph at this point. They missed their chance to arrest him long ago.

    • How wrong you are, Tonnie.
      Thank God.

      • Tonnie

        It’s kind of easy to pass a test once you know the answers though, right? And no, I still think him leading in some “recovery” effort would’ve been kind of a waste of time (of course it would have.) He didn’t help in the initial search, which was when it mattered (why would he?)
        Trying to see this through his eyes is all.
        Seems to me they had enough for an arrest years ago. I guess fear of them not getting a guilty verdict (not enough evidence) stopped them? Seems like what they had was enough once they found the first sign of his demise.
        For his mother’s sake, I’m glad this is going to be resolved. I cannot imagine knowing who killed one of my kids (ugh) and not seeing them get justice. I hope he never leaves prison alive.

    • Ka

      Stranger abductions from a home are unbelievably rare. It makes no sense that Dad left snd when he returned Dylan was gone. He was abusive to both his ex wives and kids and was a sexual freak. They also found The boys blood in several areas of the house. Also the fact Dylan made plans with a friend for early the next morning and didn’t show up means Dylan was harmed the night before. But Dad claims Dylan disappeared the next day. No question Dad killed him.