Who Was Really Buried In The Grave Of H. H. Holmes? Mystery Solved!

H. H. Holmes [Wikipedia]

YEADON, PA — Back in early May, CrimeFeed brought you the news that the body of storied con man and serial killer H. H. Holmes, aka Herman Webster Mudgett, was being exhumed for testing.

Related: The Body Of H. H. Holmes Is Being Exhumed Right Now

As far back as 1898, there were rumors that the notorious manipulator may have somehow escaped execution for his crimes. Newspaper articles of the time suggested that he may have managed to bribe his way out of his death sentence, substitute another person or medical cadaver in the noose, and slip away, possibly to South America.

A paper called the Chicago Daily Inter-Ocean reported:

“Within two hours of the hanging, an undertaker’s wagon containing a casket drove out of the prison yard. That casket was supposed to contain the body of Holmes. Instead, it contained Holmes living.”

Related: Interview: Descendant Of H. H. Holmes Makes The Case That Holmes Was Also Jack The Ripper

With renewed interest in Holmes due to continued press reports of the long-promised feature film of Erik Larsen’s Devil in the White City, set to star Leonardo diCaprio as Holmes, and the TV show American Ripper, in which Holmes descendant Jeff Mudgett attempts to prove his theory that his great-great-grandfather was also Jack the Ripper, investigators got the go-ahead to exhume whoever might be buried in Pennsylvania’s Holy Cross cemetery and verify the identity once and for all.

Much about Holmes remains a mystery, including the breadth of his criminal activity. While popularly known as a prolific serial killer, who designed his own “murder castle” in which to torture, murder, and dissect his victims, some believe that his real crimes fall more into the realm of insurance fraud and nefarious business deals. His body count is unknown, with a range of nine possible victims up to 200, depending on the source.

Related: When Criminals Get Careless: 10 Major Felons Busted For Misdemeanor Mistakes

The location of H. H. Holmes' grave in Holy Cross Cemetery [Google maps]

The location of H. H. Holmes’ grave in Holy Cross Cemetery [Google maps]

As far as the grave in Holy Cross, questions have always existed about why Holmes insisted that he be buried in a double-deep coffin, interred surrounded by cement. While he claimed at the time it was to prevent the robbing of his corpse from his grave and the probable dissection of his remains (oh, irony), others have suggested that it could have been to prevent the identification of the corpse.

Related: The Ghoulish & Unforgettable Crimes Of Murderer & Grave-Robber Ed Gein

University of Pennsylvania anthropologist Samantha Cox was in charge of the examination and testing of the remains that were exhumed from Holy Cross. While she reported that the body itself was too decomposed to allow for DNA testing, which was the original plan, she and other researchers were able to use dental records to ascertain that it was, indeed, H. H. Holmes who was laid to rest in that plot.

While the corpse itself had decayed, Cox reports that the clothes on the body were almost perfectly preserved, and the killer’s trademark mustache was still intact and attached to his skull — just as Salvador Dalí’s was, in his recent exhumation.

Related: Is He The Dada? Salvador Dalí’s Body To Be Exhumed For Paternity Test

The skeletal remains have been reinterred in the grave by the Philadelphia Archdiocese.

Read more:

The Washington Times

NBC Philadelphia

Chicago Tribune

Main photo: H. H. Holmes [Wikipedia]

  • lasheekahaaron


  • 7cathy17

    Interesting,I had heard about this recently

    • Kristina Parker

      check out the miniseries American Ripper! Amazing documentary

  • timberghost

    How can his mustache be attached to the skull? and that is bullshit that they can’t get DNA off that body!they can get it in the pulp of the tooth!

    • 7cathy17

      I would think they can ,finger nails and hair …I read somewhere that nails and hair don’t grow Post Mortum,it’s is the shrinkage of skin etc that make it appear that way .