If These Walls Could Talk: The 5 Most Infamous Murder Mansions

Taliesin Wikimedia Commons

At first glance, these five American homes are enviable and even majestic. Once you learn the dark deeds committed inside these palatial estates, you’ll appreciate your modest linoleum split-level home a whole lot more.

Related: Ted Ammon East Hampton Murder House Sells For $8 Million

Gardette LaPrete Mansion

Gardette LaPrete Mansion [Wikimedia Commons]

1) The Bloody Lore of The Gardette-LePrete Mansion 

Location: New Orleans, Louisiana

Crime: Perhaps the strangest and most sordid story in our list, the Gardette-LePrete Mansion, also known as the Sultan’s Massacre House, was built in 1836. The home was allegedly leased to the brother of a Turkish sultan, who threw extravagant parties. Tragedy befell the home when one night, the young renter, his harem, and all of his party attendees were brutally murdered. Neighbors discovered the gruesome acts when they saw blood dripping down the front steps of the home. The killers were never identified. Last we heard the home was on the market for a cool $2.65M. Guess bloodstains don’t impact property values….

Related: A Grisly New Orleans Killing: A Look Back At The Rampart Street Murder

Taliesin

Taliesin Photo [Wikimedia Commons]

2) A Gruesome Attack Forever Taints Taliesin 

Location: Spring Green, Wisconsin

Crime:  Renowned architect Frank Lloyd Wright built Taliesin in 1911. Three years later, one of the estate workers, Julian Carlton, murdered Wright’s lover, Maham Borthwick Cheney, and her two children with an ax. Carlton then set the home on fire with additional workers trapped inside. Adding to the horrific scene, Carlton stood with an ax outside of the burning home, waiting if anyone tried to escape. There was never a trial and no motive was determined before Carlton died in the weeks following the attack. The home is now a museum and National Historic Landmark, but we might leave this one off our next Frank Lloyd Wright historic homes tour.

Related: Buyer Beware! 6 Murder Houses For Sale

Mercer House

Mercer House [Wikimedia Commons]

3) Murder At Mercer House Inspires Author & Terrifies Neighbors

Location: Savannah, Georgia

Crime: Built in 1860, The Mercer House has been home to numerous tragedies. Before the murder that would be retold in John Berendt’s novel Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil, two residents died in the home. In 1913, a homeowner tripped, suffered a concussion, and died three days later, and in 1969, a boy fell from the roof and was impaled on an iron fence. The third and most notorious death was the 1981 murder of Danny Lewis Hansford. James Arthur Williams, owner of Mercer-Williams house, shot and killed his assistant and lover, Hansford. Williams was tried for the same murder four times but, after a mistrial and overturned convictions, Williams was found not guilty. The home is currently owned by Williams’ sister and is open for public tours. We’re hoping the roof is not accessible during public visits….

Related: 2 Bodies In The Bedroom: The Greystone Mansion Murder Mystery

Glensheen Estate

Glensheen Estate [Wikimedia Commons]

4) Greed Corrupts at the Glensheen Historic Estate 

Location: Duluth, Minnesota

Crime: The Gleensheen Estate is known for two reasons — historical significance and murder. Homeowner Elisabeth Congdon and her nurse, Velma Pietila, were murdered in Glensheen on June 27, 1977. Congdon was the millionaire heir to mining magnate Chester Adgate Congdon. At the age of 83, Elisabeth was suffocated in her bed, and her nurse was beaten to death with a candlestick. Elisabeth’s daughter, Majorie, and son-in-law, Roger, were arrested for the murders. Only Roger spent time behind bars and left a note, asserting his innocence, when he later committed suicide. Marjorie, who was set to inherit $8.5M from her mother, never got the money from her mother’s estate and has been charged with fraud and arson multiple times since being acquitted from her mother’s murder. Glensheen is now open to public tours, which include a brief mention of the murders. With a legacy like that, it’s probably best that the home is off the market.

Related: “Horror House” Couple Accused Of Abducting, Torturing & Murdering Women Lured Online

Amityville

Amityville [Wikimedia Commons]

5) Family Feud Erupts in Amityville 

Location: Amityville, Long Island

Crime: More than 40 years ago, six of the DeFoe family members were murdered in their home in Amityville. The homeowner couple and four of their children were found shot to death in their expensive Long Island Colonial-style home. The family’s oldest son, Ronald DeFeo, told neighbors that he found the bodies upon returning home from work. Ronald’s story soon exposed serious inconsistencies and he eventually confessed to the murders. Ronald’s defense claimed he was suffering from insanity and had been hearing voices plotting against him. Ronald was ultimately found guilty on six counts of second-degree murder and sentenced to six concurrent sentences of 25 years to life. Since his conviction, Ronald has claimed various people, including his mother and siblings were guilty of the murders. None of Ronald’s claims have been effective in overturning his sentence, and his appeals to the parole board have been denied. Ronald’s ever-evolving explanation of the night’s events is a conspiracy theorist’s dream come true.

Related: The Real Amityville Horror: A Look Back At The DeFeo Murders

Watch Investigation Discovery’s Behind Mansion Walls on ID Go now!

Recommended For You:

Watch Now: Husband & Wife Accused Of Setting Fire To Their Home — But Was It An Ex?

Watch Now: Take A Deep, Intimate Look Into The Gripping Investigation & Explosive Trial Of The Scott & Laci Peterson Case

Watch Now: Charles Stuart Claims A Black Man Killed His Wife & Unborn Baby. Boston Racial Tensions Rise — But A Surprise Confession Turns The Case Upside Down

Main photo: Wikimedia Commons

  • Tabloids_Suck

    I seriously want to spend a night in the Amityville house.

    • Karl N Karissa Crofts

      Me too! I want to in all of them, but definitely the Amityville house!

    • Karina Marciniak

      You have a true flair for the sinister and gruesome side of life, don’t you? Lol!

      • Tabloids_Suck

        Probably. Lol
        I mean, I watch crime shows all day and read about serial killers.
        There is something somewhat fascinating about learning how and why they snap.

    • WaffleFlammen

      Sadly, it’s been torn down and replaced

      • Matt Gleason

        It hasn’t. The windows were replaced and the street address was changed from 112 to 108 – other than that, house remains as it was.

  • Cheri

    It’s DeFeo, not Defoe!!

  • Guest

    Every Time crimefeed with you
    ————— SEE MORE INFO<—– <<<<

  • chikambura59

    __________?hhhiii dears 77dollors in one hours with crimefeed —- Find More __________?

  • Marianne Moravecka

    Please put more full episodes of “Mansion and Murders.” Love that show!

  • Well one mansion is too scary to even be on the same street on, the LaLaurie mansion on Royal Street in New Orleans. I haven’t seen it, but I’ve heard people faint, and hardened skeptics just freaked out. Nicolas Cage owned it.